Can we expect a commentator to be totally impartial?

Jehan Malherbe is the top caller imvho...he calls without frills and even in close calls he usually gets it right although he "plays it safe" mostly by allowing the judge to confirm the finish.

Alistair by far the best in SA

If u saw the running of race 7 at scottsville u will see why graig peters are not called eagle eye for nothing

Rockspider Wrote:

---

> If u saw the running of race 7 at scottsville u
> will see why graig peters are not called eagle eye
> for nothing


Top comentator!! Always has been.
Jehan also very good.
Clyde Basel excellent comentator,can pick out a horse along way out.
Nico/alistar have got along way to go to get close to the above 3

no

alterego Wrote:

---

> In view of the call on the finish of the Horse
> Chestnut, is it possible for commentators to be
> totally unattached from the the race. In my
> opinion Clyde was willing CTN to win so much so
> that he misjudged the finish on the replay?
> Other emotional examples include aussie jims tone
> n voice when nolan almost blew it on Black Caviar
> or Graeme Hawkins "you bring him home call" for
> Horse Chestnut.
If u listened properly clyde did not call the winner in the commentry. On the slow mo he thought cTN go up because of the angle. He is def the best caller in SA

The same situation arises with sports like soccer as well. The guest commentators are somethings so blatantly biased, it's actually a disgrace.

How are those Aussie cricket/rugby commentators ? The worst !
Our racing commentators are stars compared to Sweedish harness racing ! Nothing wrong with our boytjies well except maybe old Dumpie. Most entertaining though !