Stalls Opening Early
- Thor
-
Topic Author
- Platinum Member
-
- Posts: 2783
- Thanks: 468
Stalls Opening Early
11 years 9 months ago
Earlier at turf 3 stalls opened early. All 3 ran unplaced. No action was taken. I am assuming that if the horse had won, it wouldve been disqualified. So, because their shit gates cant open on time, once the gates open early, are we on a hiding to nothing? Is my assumption correct? Lose if we win, lose if we lose.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- flaunt
-
- Premium Member
-
- Posts: 881
- Thanks: 83
Re: Re: Stalls Opening Early
11 years 9 months ago
Correct ! Think what's more astonishing is how the starter did not see it. The stipes felt it had no impact on the result ? Not the point, it's plain and simple a false start.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Guest
-
- Visitor
-
Re: Re: Stalls Opening Early
11 years 9 months ago
Hi guys.
I would like to punt. Can you please tell me how I can join this exciting game.
Thanks guys.
I would like to punt. Can you please tell me how I can join this exciting game.
Thanks guys.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Frodo
-
- Platinum Member
-
- Posts: 13116
- Thanks: 3031
Re: Re: Stalls Opening Early
11 years 9 months ago
As I stated on the Turffontein thread, it was daylight robbery imo - I did not catch any of the presenters on TT even questioning this - too scared to rock the boat - how could the starter not see it, it was shown to the world after the race; should have been a false start and the race declared null and void - at least from a punting perspective. (td)
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- rob faux
-
- New Member
-
- Thanks: 0
Re: Re: Stalls Opening Early
11 years 9 months ago
Thor Wrote:
> Earlier at turf 3 stalls opened early. All 3 ran
> unplaced. No action was taken. I am assuming that
> if the horse had won, it wouldve been
> disqualified. So, because their shit gates cant
> open on time, once the gates open early, are we on
> a hiding to nothing? Is my assumption correct?
> Lose if we win, lose if we lose.
This is one of those interesting predicaments cos the point is very valid..............but of course there is an alternative view that says if the horse couldn't win or place with an advantage,it wasn't going to without it!!!
> Earlier at turf 3 stalls opened early. All 3 ran
> unplaced. No action was taken. I am assuming that
> if the horse had won, it wouldve been
> disqualified. So, because their shit gates cant
> open on time, once the gates open early, are we on
> a hiding to nothing? Is my assumption correct?
> Lose if we win, lose if we lose.
This is one of those interesting predicaments cos the point is very valid..............but of course there is an alternative view that says if the horse couldn't win or place with an advantage,it wasn't going to without it!!!
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Bob Brogan
-
- Administrator
-
- Posts: 82472
- Thanks: 6448
Re: Re: Stalls Opening Early
11 years 9 months ago
rob faux Wrote:
> Thor Wrote:
>
>
> > Earlier at turf 3 stalls opened early. All 3
> ran
> > unplaced. No action was taken. I am assuming
> that
> > if the horse had won, it wouldve been
> > disqualified. So, because their shit gates cant
> > open on time, once the gates open early, are we
> on
> > a hiding to nothing? Is my assumption correct?
> > Lose if we win, lose if we lose.
>
> This is one of those interesting predicaments cos
> the point is very valid..............but of course
> there is an alternative view that says if the
> horse couldn't win or place with an advantage,it
> wasn't going to without it!!!
whether they have run unplaced or not i`m a great believer that if the stalls open when they should have the race runs like its meant to be run,but if some horses get the jump this efects how a straight run race would be run..
the above is a bit of a Eric Cantona moment but i know what i mean
> Thor Wrote:
>
>
> > Earlier at turf 3 stalls opened early. All 3
> ran
> > unplaced. No action was taken. I am assuming
> that
> > if the horse had won, it wouldve been
> > disqualified. So, because their shit gates cant
> > open on time, once the gates open early, are we
> on
> > a hiding to nothing? Is my assumption correct?
> > Lose if we win, lose if we lose.
>
> This is one of those interesting predicaments cos
> the point is very valid..............but of course
> there is an alternative view that says if the
> horse couldn't win or place with an advantage,it
> wasn't going to without it!!!
whether they have run unplaced or not i`m a great believer that if the stalls open when they should have the race runs like its meant to be run,but if some horses get the jump this efects how a straight run race would be run..
the above is a bit of a Eric Cantona moment but i know what i mean

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- rob faux
-
- New Member
-
- Thanks: 0
Re: Re: Stalls Opening Early
11 years 9 months ago
hibernia Wrote:
> rob faux Wrote:
>
>
> > Thor Wrote:
> >
>
>
> >
> > > Earlier at turf 3 stalls opened early. All 3
> > ran
> > > unplaced. No action was taken. I am assuming
> > that
> > > if the horse had won, it wouldve been
> > > disqualified. So, because their shit gates
> cant
> > > open on time, once the gates open early, are
> we
> > on
> > > a hiding to nothing? Is my assumption
> correct?
> > > Lose if we win, lose if we lose.
> >
> > This is one of those interesting predicaments
> cos
> > the point is very valid..............but of
> course
> > there is an alternative view that says if the
> > horse couldn't win or place with an
> advantage,it
> > wasn't going to without it!!!
>
>
> whether they have run unplaced or not i`m a great
> believer that if the stalls open when they should
> have the race runs like its meant to be run,but if
> some horses get the jump this efects how a
> straight run race would be run..
>
> the above is a bit of a Eric Cantona moment but i
> know what i mean
Wouldn't argue with that.................that is the problem with the inconsistent application of rules.
Rules should be clearly defined and then enforced accordingly.........would end a lot of the really angry threads!
> rob faux Wrote:
>
>
> > Thor Wrote:
> >
>
>
> >
> > > Earlier at turf 3 stalls opened early. All 3
> > ran
> > > unplaced. No action was taken. I am assuming
> > that
> > > if the horse had won, it wouldve been
> > > disqualified. So, because their shit gates
> cant
> > > open on time, once the gates open early, are
> we
> > on
> > > a hiding to nothing? Is my assumption
> correct?
> > > Lose if we win, lose if we lose.
> >
> > This is one of those interesting predicaments
> cos
> > the point is very valid..............but of
> course
> > there is an alternative view that says if the
> > horse couldn't win or place with an
> advantage,it
> > wasn't going to without it!!!
>
>
> whether they have run unplaced or not i`m a great
> believer that if the stalls open when they should
> have the race runs like its meant to be run,but if
> some horses get the jump this efects how a
> straight run race would be run..
>
> the above is a bit of a Eric Cantona moment but i
> know what i mean

Wouldn't argue with that.................that is the problem with the inconsistent application of rules.
Rules should be clearly defined and then enforced accordingly.........would end a lot of the really angry threads!
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Observer1
-
- New Member
-
- Thanks: 0
Re: Re: Stalls Opening Early
11 years 9 months ago
avanza Wrote:
> Hi guys.
> I would like to punt. Can you please tell me how I
> can join this exciting game.
> Thanks guys.
Avanza,
You smoking something.
If you want to make this exciting game exciting, try exiting...and then convey same to the many sucker punters who! are been conned, by self serving money suckers.
Pull out the investors ( read punters), and the the self appointed controllers of this game, will no longer have any control.
Let those who claim to be passionate about this game, keep it going.....do it with their own money, not mine
> Hi guys.
> I would like to punt. Can you please tell me how I
> can join this exciting game.
> Thanks guys.
Avanza,
You smoking something.
If you want to make this exciting game exciting, try exiting...and then convey same to the many sucker punters who! are been conned, by self serving money suckers.
Pull out the investors ( read punters), and the the self appointed controllers of this game, will no longer have any control.
Let those who claim to be passionate about this game, keep it going.....do it with their own money, not mine
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.108 seconds